First topic message reminder :

The title explains most of it. Basically, first, you look at the person who commented last, and rate their favourite card. so, basically, first comes the rate itself (out of 10) then the reasons why, (please don't actually criticize the actual duel skill of the player just because they picked a card you don't like, treat others the way you want to be treated.) then you post your favourite card to finish your post. The cycle goes on and on. Here's an example.

Soitsu

Well, it's got 0 attack and 0 defense, and it's a normal monster. The only potential I personally see in this card is through the "itsu" unions, and, what else? Heart of the underdog? Honestly, it isn't even worth a birthright.

Ok, Easy enough to follow, right? I'll start.

Rainbow Dragon.

6/10
good as a side deck card , other than that its useless.

Ancient Sacred Wyvern.

Never fancied it. 5/10

fuh-rin-ka-zan.

seems hard to play 5.5/10

legendary 6 samurai kizan

4/10
The card is broke and needs to be Semi-Limited or Limited.

Judgment Dragon

8/10

I don't like the way it looks.

Queen Madolche Tiaramisu

7/10 It's good in madolche but Not played anywhere else.

Pot of avarice

7/10
A free +1 and shuffles monsters into deck, but requires 5 monsters. Terrible first turn draw unless you have something that can guarantee it's use.
Great near-endgame card.

Elemental HERO Flame Wingman

8/10 classic card is classic

legendary six samurai shi en

7/10 cuz its annoying
soul drain

8/10

pahunder

i really dont like thunder in piticular....


Bait doll[not my favorite but wanan know what poeple think]

Bumping.

meh 6/10, who uses that anymore?

Gateway of the six.

9/10 its too good and needs a ban D:

ultimate axon kicker :<

10/10 Lol they reference kicking butts

Hieratic dragon tefnuit.

1/10

Esper Girl

5/10
I hate psychics
The Calculator

7/10
annoying as hell that card should go to hell.

Obnoxious Celtic guardian. (its my fav card since a little kid dont even care if it scks.)

7/10 cuz of the New card art and he looks like link
night beam

6/10 good removal

Darkness Neosphere

10/10
Gorz with 4000 atk
I run him in half my decks
Rel1nquished

9/10.
Dimensional Alchemist(one of my favorites).

10/10 necroface=PWN

Kuriboh

10/10
Its too pro.

Necrovalley

7/10 (This card fucked me over so many times)

Dark Simorgh

8/10
Penguin Soldier :)